DP Quiz

A Needless Argument

hubbardThe Sun newspaper reports that a quizmaster on a small Scottish island has abandoned his weekly quiz gig after a row about a question.

Angus McPhee ran the quiz at the Colonsay Hotel and asked: "What did Old Mother Hubbard keep in her cupboard?"

One team answered "bones" but the quizmaster marked it wrong, claiming that the answer was "nothing". The team (who were heading for their seventh win in a row) lost the quiz by one point, became upset and subsequently ran a petition round the island asking local people what they thought the answer should be.

When the quizmaster heard about this, he apparently took the huff and cancelled the quiz saying that if folk were that upset, they could run it themselves.

Quizmaster (huffy) and quizgoers (petty) are both at fault here but it's a needless fandango; McPhee should have accepted their answer.

His question was ambiguous: the poem makes it clear that Old Mother Hubbard must have normally kept bones in her cupboard but on this occasion, the cupboard was bare.

The question fails to distinguish which temporal state the quizmaster was referring to It's a bad question and he should have had the grace to admit it on the spot.

Full story in the Sun is here.

 

DP Quiz is free to you. Please help me by sharing this page on:

Digg    Facebook    StumbleUpon   
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Banner

Dr Paul's Twitter Fact Feed

OBSESSIVE FACT: The Bible has been translated into Klingon, the made-up language from Star Trek.

Pub Quiz Tweets

cyberdoyle (cyberdoyle) : sat in the village pub after WI cheese and wine. Bottom in quiz. won a vase in the raffle. free wifi so demoing streetview and twitter ;)

MattOakleyMojo (Matt Oakley) : Pub Quiz fans. Excellent App for iPhone called ipubquiz. Bit biased as I designed graphics but it's very good for £1.19.

rantspub (RANTS Landlord) : Question 18 - Nightly Pub Quiz - WHO'S THE ACTOR IN THIS PICTURE? http://bit.ly/bLjq7f

JimmyEatNews (Jimmy Eat World News) : 3/15: St. Patty's Day Pub Quiz - NBC Washington: 3/15: St. Patty's Day Pub QuizNBC WashingtonThe California native... http://bit.ly/c8LBlc

baarameweleeds (Verity Britton) : Guild meeting over and I survived. The sheep quiz seemed to work. Now in pub with an old drinking partner. Quality.